少点错误 03月28日 02:12
An argument for asexuality
index_new5.html
../../../zaker_core/zaker_tpl_static/wap/tpl_guoji1.html

 

本文探讨了现状偏见,这是一种认知偏差,人们倾向于维持现状,仅仅因为改变会导致不同。文章区分了理性选择和现状偏见,指出当改变现状在综合考量下是合理的,但人们仍倾向于维持现状时,才是现状偏见。为了克服这种偏见,有时需要忽略改变的成本,从而评估最优状态。文章通过一个假设的案例,探讨了无成本改变下的决策,并提出了一个关于性取向的思考实验,最终引出了对现状偏见的反思。

🤔 现状偏见是指人们倾向于维持当前状态,仅仅因为其他状态是不同的。这是一种认知偏差,与理性决策形成对比。

💡 要克服现状偏见,有时需要忽略改变的成本。识别最优状态后,再评估改变的成本是否高到足以维持现状。

🤔 在无改变成本的情况下,选择应仅基于哪个状态更好。例如,如果性取向是令人烦恼的,那么改变它可能是有利的。

💊 文章通过一个关于性取向的假设案例,探讨了在无成本改变下,人们是否会选择改变现状。例如,一个无性恋者是否会选择改变自己的性取向。

🧐 文章提出了一个问题,即在改变成本很小的情况下,人们是否应该采取行动。例如,服用药物来消除性欲。

Published on March 27, 2025 6:08 PM GMT

Status quo bias is a cognitive bias which makes a person prefer to maintain the current state of affairs simply because other states of affairs would be different. (Henceforth, I will use the abbreviation "SOA" for "state of affairs"). 

Suppose the costs of changing the current SOA are high enough to offset any advantage a different SOA may have over the current one. Suppose that, for this reason, somebody prefers to keep the current state of affairs. Their preference is, importantly, not an instance of status quo bias. Status quo bias occurs when it would be rational, all things considered, to change the current SOA, and yet a person prefers to keep it, simply because it is the current one. 

To overcome status quo bias, it can sometimes be useful to completely ignore the costs of making changes. Once we identify an optimal SOA, we can ask: are the costs of bringing about this SOA really so high as to justify maintaining the status quo? 

Now, if there are no costs to making changes, then the answer to

i) Should I bring about SOA1, given the current state of affairs SOA2?

ii) Should I bring about SOA2, given the current state of affairs SOA1?

should be the same, and should depend only on whether SOA2 is better than SOA1

With that in mind, suppose you are asexual. Would you take a pill to make you not asexual? If you are like me, your sexuality is a nuisance (and is sometimes worse than a nuisance). Personally, I would not take this pill. I wouldn't see any compelling reason to induce in myself the desire to have sex. Therefore, being asexual is not worse for me than being not asexual, and is probably better. Therefore, I should become asexual, unless the costs of becoming asexual are high enough as to justify remaining heterosexual (that might be true if, for instance, I was in a relationship). 

Does this argument work in your case? Amusingly, there are pills that effectively eliminate libido. For men, these are "anti-androgens." The cost of taking these pills seems pretty small. Am I rationally required to take them?



Discuss

Fish AI Reader

Fish AI Reader

AI辅助创作,多种专业模板,深度分析,高质量内容生成。从观点提取到深度思考,FishAI为您提供全方位的创作支持。新版本引入自定义参数,让您的创作更加个性化和精准。

FishAI

FishAI

鱼阅,AI 时代的下一个智能信息助手,助你摆脱信息焦虑

联系邮箱 441953276@qq.com

相关标签

现状偏见 认知偏差 决策 理性 改变
相关文章
学习获得快速进步的一个关键是:尽快承认自己不行。 承认自己不行,不是指丧失自信,而是以一种白纸心态,从零开始。这是一种不小看对手的谦逊心态。 很多人是相...
AI for Enterprise Decisioning at Scale with Rob Walker - #573
我如何迭代我的知识体系: 一、痛点 最近在写flomo的时候发现了几个痛点: 1、现有的体系,不足以包涵我所有的需求。 2、已经撰写好的文字,后续提取出来难度很...
穷人应该思考的问题: 1、如何在信息不充分的情况下做出决策? 2、如何降低信息差? 3、如何在资源匮乏的条件下解决问题? 4、如何知道自己不知道的事情? 5、如...
没有所谓「真我」。 有的只是流动的我,比如这时的我,那时的我,比如说觉得去年自己是傻逼。 有的只有某一面的我,比如在家的我,在外的我,生活的我,工作的我...
黑天鹅:如何应对不可预知的未来
扔掉心里的锚
我已经吐槽过好几次现在自媒体喜欢宣传轻易的成功这事儿有多有毒了。 宣传轻易的成功,会让人觉得大多数事儿都很简单,大多数人都比我优秀,就我成一件「简单」...
一些我解决焦虑的方法,供大家参考。 1.还没完成的事使人焦虑,那就尽快(最好立刻)着手去做。 2.无法立即完成的焦虑事项,树立小的、切实可行的阶段目标和计划...
做AI的精英们,千万不要忘了全人类的平均智商是什么水平。 你费尽心思把ai打磨到能帮人写论文的copilot程度,但老百姓压根不需要写论文。 对普通老百姓,你哪怕...