AI 2 People 15小时前
I Tested TradingView for 30 Days: Here’s what really happened
index_new5.html
../../../zaker_core/zaker_tpl_static/wap/tpl_guoji1.html

 

TradingView不仅是一个图表工具,更是一个功能强大的交易操作系统和AI交易机器人启动平台。用户可以使用其专有的Pine Script语言编写、回测和优化交易策略,并通过实时警报和Webhook功能与第三方执行系统集成,实现自动化交易。该平台集成了数据、策略开发、社区共享和模拟交易等多种功能,为交易者提供了一个从策略构思到验证的完整生态系统。虽然TradingView本身不执行交易,但它为用户构建和验证AI风格的交易策略提供了核心的“引擎室”,让数据与决策相结合,并通过外部机器人执行订单。

📊 **核心功能:图表与策略开发** TradingView是一个集图表绘制、策略开发、回测和实时警报于一体的交易平台,支持股票、加密货币、外汇、商品和指数等多种资产类别。其核心在于允许用户使用Pine Script语言编写自定义的交易策略,如移动平均线交叉、MACD指标触发或蜡烛图模式识别,并能在图表上直接进行回测。

🤖 **AI策略的启动平台** 该平台并非传统的AI交易机器人,而是被描述为一个“机器人启动平台”。用户可以在TradingView中构建和验证AI风格的交易策略,并通过警报系统的Webhook功能将其连接到外部的交易执行系统,实现自动化交易。这意味着TradingView是策略的“引擎室”,而实际的订单执行则由第三方机器人完成。

💡 **社区与集成能力** TradingView拥有庞大的社区,用户可以分享、导入和改编各种脚本和策略,获取“众包智能”。此外,它还支持与第三方自动化服务(如Tickerly、Cornix、WunderTrading等)集成,通过Webhook将警报和交易信号传递给这些服务,从而实现实际的交易执行。平台还提供Paper Trading模拟器,帮助用户在投入真实资金前进行策略测试和调试。

📈 **优势与劣势并存** 该平台在Pine Script编辑器、回测能力、社区资源和模拟交易方面表现出色,但对于不熟悉编程的用户来说,学习曲线较陡峭。其策略和警报功能可能需要付费订阅,且交易执行功能并非原生集成,需要依赖外部服务,这增加了额外的成本和复杂性。同时,存在过度优化策略的风险。

💰 **定价与价值** TradingView提供不同级别的订阅计划,免费版本提供基础图表功能,付费版本则解锁更多高级功能,如警报数量、多时间框架策略等。虽然平台本身不收取自动化交易费用,但用户需要为第三方执行服务支付额外费用。这种分离的模式使得用户可以根据自身需求控制成本。

You sign up for TradingView thinking it’s “just charts,” but quickly discover it’s more like a trading operating system. Not an AI‑bot in the classic sense—it’s more like a bot launchpad. You build strategies in Pine Script, backtest them, and fire alerts which you can webhook into execution systems. Got your adrenaline pumping yet?

What Exactly Is TradingView?

TradingView is primarily a charting and strategy development platform—used across stocks, crypto, forex, commodities, indices—offering backtesting, scripting, community code, and real-time alerts. It doesn’t execute trades itself—but integrates tightly with third‑party bot services via alert webhooks.

So yes, it’s a tool for building and validating your AI‑style strategies—but execution lives elsewhere. Imagine TradingView as the engine room where data meets decisions, and bots outside fire off orders when conditions are met.

Feature Tour: What It Brings (and Leaves Out)

    Pine Script Strategy Builder
    Write or tweak strategies using built-in or custom code—RSI crossovers, MACD triggers, candle patterns, you name it. Backtest directly on chart.Alert System with Webhook Support
    You define the conditions, embed webhook URL and payload format—integration platforms then act on alerts to execute real trades.Community & Marketplace
    Tons of shared scripts and strategies. You can import community tools, read feedback, and adapt them. Great crowd‑sourced intelligence.Paper Trading Simulator
    Run your strategies in demo mode before risking real money—super helpful for debugging and confidence-building.Data & Broker Integration
    Access real-time historical data, and connect with brokers via third-party tools like Tickerly, Cornix, WunderTrading, TradersPost, etc.

My Journey: From Setup to (Almost) Live Trades

I started scribbling a simple MA crossover Pine Script strategy, ran it through backtest—it looked promising. That buzz of charts turning green? Priceless. Then I set up an alert with a webhook to a trial bot provider. Set it to paper‑trade.

Week one: alerts triggered, trades logged. Paper P&L? Meh—small pips here, tiny losses there. Felt like steering a ship through fog: promising, but nerve-wracking when hits dried up.

Then community script I borrowed flagged a reversal candle pattern that coincided with a sudden move in ETH. I saw the alert, jumped in myself—not fully automated. That little 2% move on paper felt like validation. Emotional high.

But alerts mis-fired one morning (bug in my code), and that sent me spiraling into strategy debugging. The community forums were lifesavers—someone had the exact fix. That’s empathy in code-land.

Pros & Cons Table

ProsCons / Caveats
Super‑powerful Pine Script editor + backtestingSteep learning curve if you don’t code or script
Massive community & marketplace of strategiesExecution not native—needs external bot services
Supports multivariable strategies, alerts, detailed logicAlerts and scripts often behind pay‑wall tiers
Paper trading & live chart simulatorNo direct trade execution feature
Works across multiple asset classes globallyRisk of over‑optimizing strategies on past data

What It Feels Like

There were mornings I woke up to alerts pinging my phone—felt like mission control. Other times, nothing fired all day and I second-guessed the setup. Emotional swings—hope mixed with frustration.

Seeing P&L zero out or go red hit me harder than expected. Yet debugging scripts—patching code after a false alert—felt oddly satisfying. There’s pride in ironing out bugs, seeing your logic catch a breakout.

Pricing & Value

TradingView has tiered subscription plans. Free tier gives basic charting; paid levels unlock alerts, multi-timeframe strategies, extended data, alert quantity. No direct trade automation cost—but you’ll pay bot services separately. Platforms like Tickerly or Cornix start ~$19–39/month after trials.(turn0search13, turn0search2)

Combined, price is reasonable—you’re in control of spend by mixing strategy building on TradingView with a separate execution layer.

Final Verdict (My Two Cents)

TradingView isn’t a turnkey AI‑bot—it’s the canvas where you design your bots. If you’re cool with writing or adapting strategies, testing them, and hooking up to external execution tools, this platform is gold. It doesn’t do everything for you—but it empowers you to do most of it.

If you’re expecting an all-in-one hands-off bot solution—you’ll need to look elsewhere or build the missing pieces.

Suggested Use Approach

Bottom Line: Should You Use TradingView?

Yes—if you’re willing to learn scripting, test thoroughly, and manually bridge execution. It becomes powerful in the right hands: a precision tool for traders who like building rather than being handed a black‑box.

Want help crafting a Pine Script template or setting up alert payloads for a webhook? I’m happy to help map it out.

Fish AI Reader

Fish AI Reader

AI辅助创作,多种专业模板,深度分析,高质量内容生成。从观点提取到深度思考,FishAI为您提供全方位的创作支持。新版本引入自定义参数,让您的创作更加个性化和精准。

FishAI

FishAI

鱼阅,AI 时代的下一个智能信息助手,助你摆脱信息焦虑

联系邮箱 441953276@qq.com

相关标签

TradingView 交易策略 Pine Script 自动化交易 AI交易
相关文章