While sticking to the main narrative and established character arcs of The Last of Us, Season 1 of HBO's Naughty Dog adaptation made a few notable changes. It's what made the show such an excellent adaptation, with creators Craig Mazin and Neil Druckmann expanding the world of The Last of Us by pulling on specific threads from the game.
So, how is The Last of Us Season 2 different from The Last of Us Part II?
We're going to dig in every week, updating per episode, to analyse the changes we're seeing onscreen. There'll be a few spoilers from the game for analysis' sake, so if you'd rather the narrative remain a mystery, turn back now. For the rest of you, let's get into it.
Tommy and Maria have a son.
In Season 2, Ellie (Bella Ramsey) and Joel (Pedro Pascal) are back living in the town of Jackson, Wyoming, and have reunited with family — namely Joel's brother, Tommy, (Gabriel Luna) and Tommy's wife, Maria (Rutina Wesley), two of Jackson's leaders. But with this pair comes a new character to The Last of Us, one who didn't appear in the Part II game: their son, Benjamin (Ezra Agbonkhese).
Joel goes to therapy.
In Season 2, episode 1, Joel attends one of his therapy sessions with a whisky-drinking, weed-smoking psychotherapist named Gail (Catherine O'Hara) — a fabulous character written for the TV show. A man who truly would benefit from such treatment, Joel does not have the opportunity to process his trauma in this post-apocalyptic nightmare in the game. Instead, we do get a scene at the very beginning of the game in which Joel confesses his actions in Salt Lake City to Tommy (the show has decided to omit this scene from episode 1, instead having Tommy tell Ellie not to talk about her immunity).
In the show, Joel's therapist admits she hates him for killing her husband Eugene, a character who's mentioned in the game as a Jackson resident, electronics whiz, and weed-loving mentor to Dina who left his family to join the Fireflies and died at 73 of a stroke (a rarity in this world). In the show, he died younger than that and at Joel's hands, probably because he was Infected.
We're glad the show included Eugene's secret weed basement in episode 2, but in a change, Ellie takes shelter here with Jesse (Young Mazino); in the game she's with Dina and more than weed-smoking occurs.
There's Cordyceps in the pipes and an attack on Jackson.
Uhhhh, you see that Cordyceps growing in the pipes near Jackson? That's not in the game. Druckmann and Mazin included this fungal infiltration in the series in episode 1, setting up one of the most stressful episodes of the series to date.
The Last of Us Season 2, episode 2 blowtorches the candle at both ends. At the same time as Joel's final moments in the mountain lodge, Jackson finds itself under attack by not only waves of Infected, but smart Infected who change tactics during the siege. It's an entire sequence written for the TV show and it's a true nail-biter.
We learn Abby's motive very early in the season.
By the second episode of Season 2, we know exactly why Abby (Kaitlyn Dever) has plans of revenge for Joel. We first meet Abby and her crew in episode 1 at the site of the Fireflies' massacre in Salt Lake City, a scene that makes it clear why they're hunting Joel. In episode 2, the series clearly shows us Abby's motive: Her father was the surgeon who was about to operate on Ellie before Joel killed him.
Why does this matter? Abby's association with the Fireflies and the site of Joel's massacre isn't revealed until later in the game — and it's a crucial plot point and motivation behind her character. To reveal this so early in the series is an interesting move by Mazin and Druckmann, one that gives Abby's actions more context right from the start.
Joel's death itself.
Unfortunately this traumatic narrative turn happens in both the game and the show, but there are a few differences. The events leading up to Joel's death are almost exactly the same between The Last of Us Part II and the HBO series, but there are changes — including Abby's pivot from bludgeoning to a final stab and the fact that Dina is present in the show (Tommy is there instead in the game).
Seth does slightly better than "bigot sandwiches."
It's not entirely a redemption arc, but it's damn better than a few breakfast rolls. Jackson's resident homophobe Seth (Robert John Burke) is given more opportunity to make it up to Ellie and Dina in the show, after he throws a slur at them in episode 1 for kissing at the New Year's Eve dance. We've got a breakdown of how Seth improves on his "bigot sandwiches" in the show.
It's Tommy who goes after Abby first in the game, then Ellie.
In the game, it's Tommy who leaves Jackson first to go after his brother's killers, with Ellie and Dina following in his footsteps knowing he'd be on the way to Seattle. In the show, it's Ellie and Dina who leave first, following the failed Jackson vote. And speaking of...
There's no Jackson vote in the game.
In Season 2, episode 3, Jackson takes a town hall meeting and a vote over Ellie's proposal to send a squad to track down and execute Joel's killers. It's a whole storyline over the episode, in which Ellie asks for Tommy and Jesse's support, then delivers one hell of an inspiring speech to plead with her neighbours to agree to the pitch. The vote falls against the motion, though Ellie decides to leave the town to hunt Abby and her crew anyway. But the addition of the scene allows the town of Jackson one more moment to debate what the right thing to do in such a situation is — and to give Ellie more fuel to hit the road.
Still no spores?
In The Last of Us games, characters constantly have to don masks to avoid inhaling infectious spores produced by the Cordyceps infestation. But in the show, Druckmann and Mazin decided to omit the airborne threat, instead opting for realism. "If we wanted to treat it realistically, and there are spores near, characters would wear gas masks all the time," Druckmann told Polygon of Season 1. "Then we lose so much, which is maybe the most important part of the journey, is what’s going on inside behind their eyes, in their soul, in their beings. For that logistical reason, we were like, Let’s find a different vector."
However, we spied spores in the trailer for Season 2, so perhaps we're in for some atmospheric danger?
