The first results from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) are a cosmological bombshell, suggesting that the strength of dark energy has not remained constant throughout history. Instead, it appears to be weakening at the moment, and in the past it seems to have existed in an extreme form known as “phantom” dark energy.
The new findings have the potential to change everything we thought we knew about dark energy, a hypothetical entity that is used to explain the accelerating expansion of the universe.
“The subject needed a bit of a shake-up, and we’re now right on the boundary of seeing a whole new paradigm,” says Ofer Lahav, a cosmologist from University College London and a member of the DESI team.
DESI is mounted on the Nicholas U Mayall four-metre telescope at Kitt Peak National Observatory in Arizona, and has the primary goal of shedding light on the “dark universe”. The term dark universe reflects our ignorance of the nature of about 95% of the mass–energy of the cosmos.
Intrinsic energy density
Today’s favoured Standard Model of cosmology is the lambda–cold dark matter (CDM) model. Lambda refers to a cosmological constant, which was first introduced by Albert Einstein in 1917 to keep the universe in a steady state by counteracting the effect of gravity. We now know that universe is expanding at an accelerating rate, so lambda is used to quantify this acceleration. It can be interpreted as an intrinsic energy density that is driving expansion. Now, DESI’s findings imply that this energy density is erratic and even more mysterious than previously thought.
DESI is creating a humungous 3D map of the universe. Its first full data release comprise 270 terabytes of data and was made public in March. The data include distance and spectral information about 18.7 million objects including 12.1 million galaxies and 1.6 million quasars. The spectral details of about four million nearby stars nearby are also included.
This is the largest 3D map of the universe ever made, bigger even than all the previous spectroscopic surveys combined. DESI scientists are already working with even more data that will be part of a second public release.
DESI can observe patterns in the cosmos called baryonic acoustic oscillations (BAOs). These were created after the Big Bang, when the universe was filled with a hot plasma of atomic nuclei and electrons. Density waves associated with quantum fluctuations in the Big Bang rippled through this plasma, until about 379,000 years after the Big Bang. Then, the temperature dropped sufficiently to allow the atomic nuclei to sweep up all the electrons. This froze the plasma density waves into regions of high mass density (where galaxies formed) and low density (intergalactic space). These density fluctuations are the BAOs; and they can be mapped by doing statistical analyses of the separation between pairs of galaxies and quasars.
The BAOs grow as the universe expands, and therefore they provide a “standard ruler” that allows cosmologists to study the expansion of the universe. DESI has observed galaxies and quasars going back 11 billion years in cosmic history.
nearby bright galaxies (yellow), luminous red galaxies (orange), emission-line galaxies (blue), and quasars (green). The inset shows the large-scale structure of a small portion of the universe. (Courtesy: Claire Lamman/DESI collaboration)
“What DESI has measured is that the distance [between pairs of galaxies] is smaller than what is predicted,” says team member Willem Elbers of the UK’s University of Durham. “We’re finding that dark energy is weakening, so the acceleration of the expansion of the universe is decreasing.”
As co-chair of DESI’s Cosmological Parameter Estimation Working Group, it is Elbers’ job to test different models of cosmology against the data. The results point to a bizarre form of “phantom” dark energy that boosted the expansion acceleration in the past, but is not present today.
The puzzle is related to dark energy’s equation of state, which describes the ratio of pressure of the universe to its energy density. In a universe with an accelerating expansion, the equation of state will have value that is less than about –1/3. A value of –1 characterizes the lambda–CDM model.
However, some alternative cosmological models allow the equation of state to be lower than –1. This means that the universe would expand faster than the cosmological constant would have it do. This points to a “phantom” dark energy that grew in strength as the universe expanded, but then petered out.
“It’s seems that dark energy was ‘phantom’ in the past, but it’s no longer phantom today,” says Elbers. “And that’s interesting because the simplest theories about what dark energy could be do not allow for that kind of behaviour.”
Dark energy takes over
The universe began expanding because of the energy of the Big Bang. We already know that for the first few billion years of cosmic history this expansion was slowing because the universe was smaller, meaning that the gravity of all the matter it contains was strong enough to put the brakes on the expansion. As the density decreased as the universe expanded, gravity’s influence waned and dark energy was able to take over. What DESI is telling us is that at the point that dark energy became more influential than matter, it was in its phantom guise.
“This is really weird,” says Lahav; and it gets weirder. The energy density of dark energy reached a peak at a redshift of 0.4, which equates to about 4.5 billion years ago. At that point, dark energy ceased its phantom behaviour and since then the strength of dark energy has been decreasing. The expansion of the universe is still accelerating, but not as rapidly. “Creating a universe that does that, which gets to a peak density and then declines, well, someone’s going to have to work out that model,” says Lahav.
Scalar quantum field
Unlike the unchanging dark-energy density described by the cosmological constant, a alternative concept called quintessence describes dark energy as a scalar quantum field that can have different values at different times and locations.
However, Elbers explains that a single field such as quintessence is incompatible with phantom dark energy. Instead, he says that “there might be multiple fields interacting, which on their own are not phantom but together produce this phantom equation of state,” adding that “the data seem to suggest that it is something more complicated.”
Before cosmology is overturned, however, more data are needed. On its own, the DESI data’s departure from the Standard Model of cosmology has a statistical significance 1.7σ. This is well below 5σ, which is considered a discovery in cosmology. However, when combined with independent observations of the cosmic microwave background and type Ia supernovae the significance jumps 4.2σ.
“Big rip” avoided
Confirmation of a phantom era and a current weakening would be mean that dark energy is far more complex than previously thought – deepening the mystery surrounding the expansion of the universe. Indeed, had dark energy continued on its phantom course, it would have caused a “big rip” in which cosmic expansion is so extreme that space itself is torn apart.
“Even if dark energy is weakening, the universe will probably keep expanding, but not at an accelerated rate,” says Elbers. “Or it could settle down in a quiescent state, or if it continues to weaken in the future we could get a collapse,” into a big crunch. With a form of dark energy that seems to do what it wants as its equation of state changes with time, it’s impossible to say what it will do in the future until cosmologists have more data.
Lahav, however, will wait until 5σ before changing his views on dark energy. “Some of my colleagues have already sold their shares in lambda,” he says. “But I’m not selling them just yet. I’m too cautious.”
The observations are reported in a series of papers on the arXiv server. Links to the papers can be found here.
The post DESI delivers a cosmological bombshell appeared first on Physics World.
